This imposing structure was designed by Edmund Sedding to accommodate a congregation of two hundred and seventy, and erected by local builder Mr. Toy, for around £2,000.
The ashlar stonework came from the Polyphant quarries near Launceston, the "Western Echo" told its readers; while subscribers to the "St Ives weekly Summary" learnt that the granite came from Breage. Both agreed the rood was of Delabole slate.
The Bishop of Truro laid a stone with the dedication:
In Memorium
John Balmen Jones M.A.
32 years Vicar of St Ives
Died March 22nd, 1901
The Church was dedicated at a choral celebration of Holy Communion on August 10th 1905, after a procession through the streets, before a prophetically small congregation of one hundred souls.
The Bishop described it as "a great day for the fishermen of St Ives, and for the many fisher-wives and children, who would thank God for this House of Prayer". However, the down'long fishing families in the narrow streets nearby were mainly non-conformists, due in part, perhaps. to the age-old disputes with the Church over the tithes levied on the fish landed in the harbour.
John Wesley himself recorded twenty-seven visits to the town.
Whatever the reason, the church did not flourish. At it's consecration the building was described as being finished "except for the upper part of the steeple, which is left for a future generation to complete", but in a little over twenty years it closed, still without it's steeple.
The church had an organ that was pumped manually, most economically by a small boy. The author's uncle, now in his eighties, can will wax indignant over the fact that when the church closed he was never paid for his final efforts as the small boy in question.
In 1945 the Society bought the deconsecrated building for £2,800.